What makes a good property manager? Now that’s a million-dollar question you’ve all been wondering about. According to industry experts, it’s about avoiding a few common pitfalls. If these are overlooked, they can escalate into major problems, causing serious damage to your performance and wellbeing.   


Here are the most common property management mistakes that you need to avoid: 


Not planning and having a “too busy” mindset 

When there are a dozen urgent tasks on your mind, it’s tempting to skip the planning and try to handle everything at once. But this stops you from working efficiently due to a lack of focus and attempts to multitask. You end up feeling overwhelmed and burnt-out because there is no sense of direction and understanding of priority. 


Planning is essential for any job that involves a large workload. Always begin work with a list of all the tasks that need to be done by the end of the day, order them according to priority and focus on completing one task before starting the next one. Being organised gives you greater mental clarity and attention to detail. You are more likely to ensure that every loose end is tied, every request is followed up and every problem is solved.  


Not being thorough with the tenant selection process 

Tenant screening is another area that property managers need to pay extra attention to. It is important to review identification copies, references from previous landlords or agents and employment details of potential tenants.  We also strongly recommend you check the rental history of applicants using the Tenant Internet Database. Don’t forget to lodge the details of defaulting tenants after they vacate. This exposes tenants who have breached a rental contract in the past and prevents other property managers from renting them a property.  


Effective tenant screening procedures need to be in place to screen out undesirable tenants. The time you invest in completing thorough background checks is nothing compared to the costs of renting a property to the wrong people. This could be anything from rental arrears, property damages to hidden drug labs and legal disputes. 


Failing to communicate with landlords  

Studies have shown that the quality of communication is the primary factor determining a property manager’s success. This isn’t surprising for an industry based on managing relationships with landlords and tenants. Property managers are expected to promptly return calls and emails. The easiest way to manage this is to set aside specific time slots during the day to return calls and emails.  


While many property managers provide excellent tenant inductions, they should do the same for landlords as well. Otherwise, this can lead to conflicts between tenants and landlords around issues such as wear and tear, repairs and maintenance. Breakdowns in communication lead to misunderstandings, poor rapport and even lost clients.  


Property managers can prevent this by conducting a complete landlord induction using the property owner’s handbook. By being proactive and keeping communication channels open, property managers can ensure long-term tenancies, lower vacancy rates, and greater client satisfaction.  


Not documenting important information 

As a property manager, you’ll have copies of formal property management agreements with clients and leasing agreements with tenants. Apart from these documents, you should also be keeping written records of other important information. This includes photos and timestamps of damages, file notes of actions taken, conversations logs, and details of maintenance requests. Don’t attempt to store all this information in your memory. This makes things difficult for the company if you are sick, on leave or resign. Time and money can be wasted on trying to investigate a situation which could have been explained in a file note. Proper documentation will also provide you with legal protection if the need ever arises.  


Lack of attention to routine inspections and maintenance  

When you schedule too many routine inspections in a set timeframe, the inspections become rushed, and critical issues are overlooked. At the other extreme, it’s an equally bad idea to delay routine inspections and maintenance. In both cases, this results in tenants leaving behind excessive damage when they move out, costing you time, money and even your reputation.  


It’s important to inspect properties on a regular basis so you can identify and fix minor problems before they become worse. But set realistic expectations for how many you can complete in a set timeframe so that you can be thorough with each inspection. Not only will this prevent costly damages in the future, but it will also keep tenants on their toes by giving them the impression you are responsible and attentive.  


When maintenance problems arise (even minor ones), don’t allow your tenants to handle them unless you want to risk additional damages and liability for potential injury. Hiring the wrong tradesperson can also have costly repercussions, it’s important to select contractors based on their level of experience and not on price. An experienced contractor will always come with a higher fee but will produce quality results that save you money in the long run. An inexperienced contractor, on the other hand, may charge less, but the job they complete is likely to require attention again in the near future.    


Being too tolerant with rental arrears  

Another common property management pitfall is not promptly attending to rental arrears. Allowing the tenant to be over seven days or more behind can result in them being unable to pay back the overdue amount. Nearly all abandonments and evictions are caused by a failure to pay rent. This means that being tolerant with rental arrears will damage your relationship with both tenants and landlords.  


Early intervention may seem harsh but will allow the tenant to stay in the accommodation, benefiting all parties in the long run. Make it a habit to contact the tenant when they are only a few days behind so you can tackle the problem before it gets out of hand.  


Discounting fees and managing too many properties 

This is the primary reason for the high burnout and turnover rates in the property management industry. It’s a common belief within property management that charging lower fees is a sign of good service. As many property managers receive little-to-no training in winning new business, we can hardly blame them for this mistaken assumption.  


Due to low service fees, property managers must manage a larger number of properties to justify their position financially within their agency. Having more properties to manage will lead to lower service quality and increased burnout and turnover. It can also be tempting to sign up almost every property you can without considering whether the deal is profitable or not. Some of these properties will be in poor condition and difficult to manage. This further contributes to burnout and subsequent resignation of property managers. In the end, the company is left with mostly new and inexperienced staff, resulting in poor service overall.  


To overcome this issue, property management agencies should invest in training their staff on how to win new business that will generate profits. Property managers need to learn how to handle common fee objections using effective techniques that don’t involve discounting fees. By doing this, property managers will be able to manage fewer properties, allowing them to focus on the quality of their service while avoiding stress and burnout.  


Now is the time to put steps in place immediately to ensure you don‘t fall victim to these common property management pitfalls. If you delay in taking action, mistakes can turn into habits that are much more difficult to change.